Lauren Preedy – Senior Solicitor – Head of Divorce Team

Maintenance Issues

When considering maintenance issues we need to think about short-term maintenance (the period between the breakdown and achieving a long-term financial order) and also longer term maintenance issues (whether or not there can be a clean break).

Maintenance Pending Suit

This is interim maintenance – after the divorce process has been started.

Maintenance pending suit is essentially about establishing a holding position – whilst the wider and longer-term implications of the financial settlement are considered.

The sole criterion for the making of such an order in Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, s 22 is ‘reasonableness’, which is synonymous with fairness

legal 500 leading firm logoCase law has expanded on how a court should approach maintenance pending suit cases:

  • a very important factor in determining fairness is the marital standard of living, although that is not to say that the exercise is merely to replicate that standard
  • in every maintenance pending suit application, there should be a specific budget for that application that excludes capital or long-term expenditure, which is more apt to be considered at a final hearing
  • the budget should be examined critically in every case so to exclude forensic exaggeration
  • Karen Elliott – Senior Consultant Chartered Legal Executive – Divorce/ Finance Specialist

    where the sworn statement or Form E disclosed by the paying party is deficient, the court should not hesitate to make any robust assumptions about their ability to pay—the court is not confined by what the payer says about their resources and in such circumstances it should err in favour of the payee

  • where the paying party has historically been supported by an outsider, and where the payer is asserting that the third party has curtailed the financial support, but where the position is unclear or ambiguous, then the court is justified in assuming that the third party will continue to supply the financial support, at least until the final hearing

Words of Caution

Court hearings about maintenance pending suit for families with comparatively limited means can end up costing more in legal costs than the difference between what is being asked for by one of the couple and what is being offered by the other. Most solicitors will therefore

urge their clients to take a sensible approach and try and find a reasonable agreement.

Arguments about Interim Maintenance take place before a couple and their lawyers are properly able to consider the long-term financial arrangements. (Resolving the overall case will inevitably mean that short-term issues will have also been resolved).

Bridget Garrood – Senior Consultant Solicitor – Divorce/ Finance/ LGBT+ Specialist

Having a contested hearing about interim maintenance/maintenance pending suit will inevitably increase tension between the couple and there is a reasonable likelihood that this will make it harder to reach agreement about the longer-term financial arrangements. Therefore reaching sensible agreement is doubly a good idea.

General principles—spousal and civil partner periodical payments

When deciding whether a periodical payments order is appropriate, regard must be had to the checklist of factors set out in section 25 of

the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973

The most relevant factors to periodical payments are:

  • the income and earning capacity that each of the parties has or is likely to have in the foreseeable future and, in the case of earning capacity, any increase in that capacity that it would be reasonable to expect a party to take steps to acquire—see Practice Note: The income and earning capacity of the parties
  • the financial needs, obligations and responsibilities that each of the parties has or is likely to have in the foreseeable future, together with the standard of living enjoyed before the breakdown of the relationship—see Practice Note: The needs of the parties
  • Fiona Griffin – Senior Consultant Solicitor – Divorce/ Finance Specialist

    the age of each party and the duration of the relationship—see Practice Note: The age of the parties and the length of the marriage or civil partnership, and

  • any physical or mental disability of either of the parties

What is a reasonable level for periodical payments?

The rules about child maintenance are clear and in most cases the level of child maintenance is determined by the calculator that is contained on the child maintenance service website.

There is no calculator for spousal maintenance.

What is appropriate (if anything) will depend upon the circumstances of the couple.

We have referred above to the criteria in section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973.

Some factors that can be relevant include how near the couple are to retirement and the final order will address pension provision (including timing of pension income).

Is there sufficient capital to enable the spouse who might have received maintenance to receive an additional lump sum instead – which could be invested in buying an annuity or to reduce other outgoings (e.g. paying off a mortgage)

Kris Seed – Senior Chartered Legal Executive – Head of Private Law Children Team

Whether there are young children which need care and which will limit the extent to which each parent is able to work and/or to retrain so that they can maximise their earning capacity.

These can be complicated issues and it is a good idea to get legal advice at an early stage

In more complicated cases we may also advise that it would be sensible to engage the services of a financial planner – who would be able to assist in advising how assets can best be utilised.

Latest News

Somerset woman: Domestic abuse story is a lesson

A Somerset woman has told of the abuse she suffered at the hands of her partner, after he was found guilty of assaulting her. The woman has publicised her story as a warning to others not to ignore ‘red flags’ in relationships.

Read more
No-fault divorce and mediation: taking the pain out of divorce

It goes without saying that divorce can be a painful experience. Much of that pain can be caused by conflict during the process, leading to stressful contested court proceedings. But it doesn’t have to be that way.

Read more
Even if you have agreed your divorce settlement, you still need a court order

With the advent of online divorce more and more people are doing their own divorce, especially since no-fault divorce has made the process considerably simpler. And having dealt with the divorce themselves, many are tempted to go one step

Read more
No-fault divorce is great, but don’t forget the financial settlement

It is almost universally agreed that the introduction of no-fault divorce has been a good thing. Gone are the days when someone wanting a divorce has had to lay the blame for the breakdown of the marriage upon their spouse.

Read more
Marriage decline shows importance of cohabitants knowing their rights

On the 19th May the Office for National Statistics (‘ONS’) published its latest annual figures for the number of marriages that took place in England and Wales, for the year 2019. The figures show a continuing decline in marriage rates.

Read more
Dorset council exposed woman to risk of abuse from father

When a local authority has concerns over the welfare of a child it will usually assign a social worker to get in touch with the family and investigate the matter. When this happens, it is of course essential that the parents

Read more
Johnny Depp v Amber Heard: playing out your private life in public

For the last month the world has eagerly watched the Johnny Depp v Amber Heard defamation trial, as the two actors have exchanged lurid alleged details of their private lives. Seeing two Hollywood stars fighting out such a battle in court

Read more
Should Olivia Wilde have been served with child custody papers whilst on stage?

When the actress Olivia Wilde was recently served with child custody papers whilst on stage it caused something of a sensation. Surely, said many, she should not have been served publicly, whilst she was working?

Read more
How Exeter City’s persistence is a lesson for all during family court proceedings.

Many congratulations to Exeter City F.C, who last week secured automatic promotion from League Two. And the Grecians’ success came after five years of promotion near-misses, including being beaten in the final of the play-off in 2017, 2018

Read more
We are Recruiting x 3; Marketing Assistant, PA, Paralegal

We are Recruiting x 3; Marketing Assistant, PA, Paralegal The past 2 years have seen us achieve significant growth and we have firmly established ourselves as a leading regional family law solicitors practice. This year we will be joined by some additional team members who will further strengthen our team. First of these is Emma […]

Read more
Somerset Council failed to comply with adoption requirements

Somerset Council failed to comply with adoption requirements A recent High Court case has highlighted serious failures on the part of Somerset County Council to comply with the legal requirements when it has been acting as an adoption agency. Adoption agencies are organisations that work with prospective parents and children to assess, match, arrange and […]

Read more
Do I have to attend a MIAM (Mediation Information and Assessment Meeting)?

Do I have to attend a MIAM (Mediation Information and Assessment Meeting)? Anyone wishing to apply to the court about a family matter must first attend a Mediation Information and Assessment Meeting (commonly known by the acronym ‘MIAM’), unless an exemption applies. As the name suggests, the purpose of the MIAM is to provide the […]

Read more